JakeandEmmasMom
Banned From Tithing?
January 28, 2013 at 10:59 AM

 All of these posts about banning welfare recipients from spending money on X, Y, Z got me thinking.  Should welfare recipients be banned from putting money in the collection plate at church?  After all, if they can't afford to support themselves, should they really be taking the money from the government just to give some away?

Whether or not it could be enforced isn't the point.  This is a philosophical question.

Should welfare recipients be banned from putting money in the collection plate at church?
  • Only group members can vote in this poll.
  1. 20% - Yes
  2. 73% - No
  3. 5% - Other

Replies

  • katy_kay08
    January 30, 2013 at 7:16 PM


    Quoting toomanypoodles:

     

    Quoting JakeandEmmasMom:

     Are you of the opinion that government assistance is a gift from God to the poor?

    It sure isn't income.  They didn't earn it by working. 

    since the church doesn't pay taxes it isn't a gift from "God".  

    Most people that receive forms of public assistance do so for a limited time and often have paid taxes prior to receiving it as well as paying taxes both during and after.  So one could say they have "earned" the help as they paid towards it.  

  • Bigmetalchicken
    January 30, 2013 at 11:24 PM

    Not to sound unchristian, but your old church sucks.

    Quoting colins_mom:

    At my old church if you didn't tithe you couldn't participate in ANY church functions. Breakfast with the pastor, nope. You couldn't teach sunday school, you couldnt be a praise singer nothing.

    Quoting Bigmetalchicken:

    I do not think any church would expect anyone to give money that they truly could not give. I know our church doesn't. When someone at our church has a desire to tithe, but not the means, we suggest a time tithe.  Come up and help with the youth group.  Come up and help with our different service projects (we put together weekend food packs for the kids on free lunch at the school across the street, and other things like that).  There are far more ways to use your blessings to help God than just money.


  • Mama2JoshKatie
    January 30, 2013 at 11:32 PM

    I voted no because it's ridiculous. You can't ban someone from tithing. lol

  • colins_mom
    January 31, 2013 at 4:36 AM
    Yeah that's why it's my old church. My mom was s cancer patient and her only income was welfare and they still expected her to tithe. When she didnt i wasn't allowed to go to youth camp, even though i saved all year for it.

    Quoting Bigmetalchicken:

    Not to sound unchristian, but your old church sucks.

    Quoting colins_mom:

    At my old church if you didn't tithe you couldn't participate in ANY church functions. Breakfast with the pastor, nope. You couldn't teach sunday school, you couldnt be a praise singer nothing.



    Quoting Bigmetalchicken:

    I do not think any church would expect anyone to give money that they truly could not give. I know our church doesn't. When someone at our church has a desire to tithe, but not the means, we suggest a time tithe.  Come up and help with the youth group.  Come up and help with our different service projects (we put together weekend food packs for the kids on free lunch at the school across the street, and other things like that).  There are far more ways to use your blessings to help God than just money.


  • cammibear
    January 31, 2013 at 8:15 AM
    I wouldn't use the word banned, but I think welfare should only be for necessities, food, shelter, and toiletries.. If you are not earning anything then you don't really have an income to tithe from. If such person wants to give an offering, they can give of their time.