The CafeMom Newcomers Club
I have a quick question. In the new movie it shows Alice having vision with the wolves in it for example the fight. Well in New Moon Alice says she cant see anything that involves the wolves. So how is she able to see them in Breaking dawn? Is anyone as confused as I am about this?
Replies
-
I have yet to see the movie but read the books. weren't the vampires fighting with them? Maybe she was keeping an eye on the wolves looking "through" the vamps? -
I haven't seen that preview but maybe it's just one of those stupid mess ups, there were so many in Potter that I just huffed and puffed.
-
Had to refer to my 8 y/o for this one:
she doesn't remember Alice saying she couldn't see visions that involve the wolves in NM. I can't say for sure, been a while since I've seen any of them... not much help I guess.
Quoting Countrygerl:
I have a quick question. In the new movie it shows Alice having vision with the wolves in it for example the fight. Well in New Moon Alice says she cant see anything that involves the wolves. So how is she able to see them in Breaking dawn? Is anyone as confused as I am about this?
-
I never read the book but I have watched the movie many many times and I remember right after Bella jumped off the cliff and she was in the living room with Alice she said she didnt see Bella get rescued by Jacob and she said in fact I cant see anything with these mangy mutts around.
Quoting waffa:
Had to refer to my 8 y/o for this one:
she doesn't remember Alice saying she couldn't see visions that involve the wolves in NM. I can't say for sure, been a while since I've seen any of them... not much help I guess.
Quoting Countrygerl:
I have a quick question. In the new movie it shows Alice having vision with the wolves in it for example the fight. Well in New Moon Alice says she cant see anything that involves the wolves. So how is she able to see them in Breaking dawn? Is anyone as confused as I am about this?
-
I don't remember what it said in the book. In the movie she couldn't see Bella. She said she couldn't see past Jacob and his pack of muts.
Quoting waffa:
Had to refer to my 8 y/o for this one:
she doesn't remember Alice saying she couldn't see visions that involve the wolves in NM. I can't say for sure, been a while since I've seen any of them... not much help I guess.
Quoting Countrygerl:
I have a quick question. In the new movie it shows Alice having vision with the wolves in it for example the fight. Well in New Moon Alice says she cant see anything that involves the wolves. So how is she able to see them in Breaking dawn? Is anyone as confused as I am about this?
-
In the book she cant see bc of the wolves. In Breaking dawn (book) she cant see Renesmee bc she's "like the wolves". The "vision" alice has in part 2 doesnt happen in the books. My only thought is her vision is developing since they spend so much time w the wolves or bc she is in direct contact w Aro and thats how she can see what "would happen" -
bump to read all the answers :)
I will have to ask my dd, lol! -
Yup. It was definetly a blooper. I noticed it to...I've read the books and the vision didn't happen. Oh well...it was still a cool scene. What really got me is when she saw a vison of Edward Bella Jacob and Renesmee in the future... -
Honestly I didn't even notice that! Lol but when I watch movies I remind myself that they are just movies and little mistakes can happen in order to further the story.