Cafe MichelleP
Should This Child Face Jail Time or a Rehabilitation Program?
January 14, 2013 at 10:05 AM

10-Year-Old Accused of Planning & Shooting His Neo-Nazi Father While He Slept

boy killed fatherA 12-year-old boy in California stands accused of planning and executing the murder of his neo-Nazi father by shooting him while he slept on the couch two years ago. The boy was 10 and at issue is whether or not a boy that young can even know right from wrong enough to be found guilty.

The verdict was expected Monday, but the case raises some interesting questions. Can a boy raised on violence and guns and hate by a father who was a regional leader of the National Socialist Movement really be considered guilty when all he was doing was practicing what he was raised to do? He claims his father was abusive. Prosecutors claim the child was violent from the start, even stabbing a teacher with a pencil in kindergarten. Of course, both things could be true.

He could be violent because he was raised to do so. Isn't this what a neo-Nazi wants? Violence, hate, and anarchy?

In many ways, raising a child with racist, homophobic, or hateful views is abuse in itself. From the start, you are raising a child who has a closed mind and believes intolerance and hatred are good, just qualities. It's cruel.

Then, if you add violence into the mix, well then, you get out exactly what you put in. The reality is no one who is a neo-Nazi or a member of a hate group is a good person. Sorry. That's just a fact. So it doesn't take a genius to imagine that intolerance and hatred isn't solely reserved for Jewish people or African-Americans. One has to assume that sort of hate spreads itself all over. Possibly to a child.

The boy hasn't been found guilty, but if he is, it's hard to imagine how he could have turned out any other way.

Children are supposed to have open minds. They are supposed to love everyone and believe everyone is their friend. If they don't, that is something they're taught.

It isn't that a child can never be a sociopath guilty of a crime. Certainly that is possible and certainly there ARE children who are beyond repair. But a child that is taught to hate from a young age, follows through on what has been taught, and then is found guilty and sent away to juvenile prison where he will emerge even darker and MORE violent at 18 was never really given a chance at a normal, happy, loving life.

To me, that is wrong. I would rather see my tax dollars go to rehabilitating this boy and possibly giving him a shot at a regular, hate-free life.

What a tragic, tragic case.

Do you think he should go to lock-up if found guilty?

Replies

  • goddess99
    January 14, 2013 at 10:14 AM

    I think he needs a good therapist and have that therapist figure out where to place this child.

  • MistressMinerva
    January 14, 2013 at 2:20 PM

    He needs to get help and hopefully with help he can be a better person.

  • DixieFlower
    January 14, 2013 at 5:42 PM

    I agree with the above posters. I don't think that jail would do much good for this child.

  • Maida265
    January 14, 2013 at 5:56 PM

     This is a tough one...but I agree with the others. He's still so young and I always believe there is hope to rehabilitate when charged this young. Prison would only teach him more of what he's already done.

  • DragonMother10
    January 14, 2013 at 5:58 PM
    Children are born innocent and only taught to hate. If he was older, maybe jail time is the best thing. He can be re-taught how to respect.







    I also want to add, these Neo-Nazis are ridiculous. My husband is from Germany and his great-grandparents were Nazis, and he says Neo-Nazis know nothing about Nazism and how it was, they are acting like idiots. Of course Germany is different now and my husband is not a racist, obviously since I am Hispanic. Skinheads are another thing that has nothing to do with Nazism. The first skinheads started in Britain and they weren't racist, they were just rebellious, kind of like the punks. Of course people like to change things and make it into a negative impact, just like the way Hitler changed the meaning of the Swastika. The Swastika meant "being good with higher self and it is a Buddhism symbol. Hitler decided to adopt it and turn it sideways, now it is a symbol of hate.
  • notjstanothrmom
    January 14, 2013 at 6:01 PM
    No. That poor child. :( 10 is too young to know most things, let alone that murder is wrong while taught it was good to kill their whole life.

  • splatz
    by splatz
    January 14, 2013 at 11:18 PM

    I agree. I find it really sad. :(

    Quoting MistressMinerva:

    He needs to get help and hopefully with help he can be a better person.


  • Iron-range-girl
    January 15, 2013 at 12:09 PM

    I do think its wrong I do think maybe trying to correct wrong teachings to good teaching is what needs to be done it is not his fault for the way he was raised its all he knows the poor boy.

  • mommyof2andTTC
    January 15, 2013 at 12:16 PM

     He was taught that from birth and is only 10... put him in a rehabilitation center

  • la_bella_vita
    January 15, 2013 at 12:17 PM

     10 is so young. He needs a lot of help. I don't see how jail for someone so young could be a good thing.